Sutton Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Sutton, a charming town nestled in the heart of the picturesque countryside, where quaint streets and friendly faces create a warm and inviting atmosphere. With its rich history, stunning natural landscapes, and vibrant community spirit, Sutton offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. Located just a short drive from major urban centers, this hidden gem provides residents with easy access to the amenities of city life while maintaining a peaceful, rural lifestyle.

Sutton is known for its well-preserved architecture, lush parks, and a variety of recreational activities. Families and outdoor enthusiasts alike can enjoy hiking trails, fishing spots, and community events that foster a strong sense of belonging. The town's commitment to preserving its natural beauty and historical significance makes it an ideal place for those seeking a balanced lifestyle.

For homebuyers looking for affordability without sacrificing quality, Sutton offers an impressive selection of homes under $500,000. From charming bungalows to spacious family homes, there is something to suit every taste and budget. These properties often feature modern amenities, beautiful gardens, and easy access to local schools and parks, making them perfect for families, first-time buyers, or anyone looking to downsize.

In Sutton, you’ll find a welcoming community that values connection and collaboration. With homes available at accessible price points, now is the perfect time to explore all that this delightful town has to offer. Discover your dream home in Sutton and become part of this vibrant community today!

Newest Sutton Homes under $500,000

$495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5112706 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated ranch in scenic Sutton, New Hampshire, set on 2.65 acres off quiet Route 114! Offering comfortable one-level living, this inviting home features three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, convenient first-floor laundry, a bright sunroom, and a spacious deck with partial mountain views. The gorgeous, newly renovated kitchen is the heart of the home and a chef’s dream, offering a fresh, modern feel with an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. A large picture window above the sink fills the kitchen with natural light and offers a lovely view, making even those everyday chores a little more enjoyable. Enjoy the best of New Hampshire living with nearby lakes, ski mountains, snowmobile trails, and year-round recreation. Cozy up on cold winter nights after a day on the slopes, or simply unwind after a long day. Relax in the sunroom, take in the views from the deck, or enjoy the country setting from the covered front porch. The two-car attached garage provides convenient direct entry into the home, no need to step outside in the rain or snow. The walkout basement offers excellent potential for additional living space, providing plenty of room to grow. Outside, the spacious backyard offers room to enjoy the outdoors, with a fenced area ideal for animals and additional space for gardening or creating your own small homestead or equestrian setup. Offering a wonderful combination of country living, beautiful views, and convenient access to the lakes, mountains, and recreational opportunities of the Lake Sunapee/Kearsarge region, this Sutton home is ready to be enjoyed in every season. Don’t miss out on this adorable ranch, call today to schedule your private showing!

9 Rte 114, Sutton

$479,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5110688 MLS

Charm, character and a wonderful connection to Kezar Lake! This lovingly cared-for cottage-style home is steeped in local history and enjoys deeded access to more than 400 feet of shared waterfront on beautiful Kezar Lake, complete with a sandy beach. Set along Harvey Road on the way to Muster Field Farm, the location invites you to slow down and enjoy the best of Sutton. Take a morning walk around the lake, head down to the shared waterfront for an afternoon by the water, or simply enjoy the peaceful country setting from home. Inside, this year-round cottage offers three bedrooms, two full baths and 1,380 square feet of warm and welcoming living space. This is a home that truly needs to be experienced in person. There is a warmth and character here that is difficult to capture in photographs, from the beautiful birch floors and custom built-ins to the open kitchen, dining and living spaces that make the home feel comfortable and inviting the moment you step inside. An impressive stone fireplace with a Jøtul woodstove anchors the main living area and adds to the cozy cottage atmosphere, while the enclosed porch offers another inviting place to relax and enjoy the surroundings. The home's timeless character has been thoughtfully preserved while benefiting from a long list of recent improvements, including a high-efficiency propane heating system, added insulation, electrical updates, plumbing improvements and updates to the kitchen and baths. Set on 0.60 acres, 13 Harvey Road offers a special combination of history, cottage charm and access to one of Sutton's most beloved lakes. Whether you're looking for a year-round home or a peaceful New Hampshire retreat, come experience this one in person.

13 Harvey Rd, Sutton

$299,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5110577 MLS

Bean Pond is practically at your doorstep! Built in 2023 and set on 5 acres in Sutton, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath manufactured home combines the ease of a newer home with a setting made for enjoying Vermont. Take in views of Bean Pond and the surrounding hills right from the living room and expansive front deck, then simply cross the road to the Vermont Fish & Wildlife fishing and boating access. With the driveway located directly across from the access, getting a kayak, canoe, or boat on the water couldn’t be much easier. Inside, the open floor plan connects the living, dining, and kitchen spaces, with large windows keeping the pond and hillside views front and center. The kitchen features a large center island, abundant cabinetry and counter space, stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash, and range hood. The primary suite offers a spacious bedroom, walk-in closet, and private bath with double vanity. Two additional bedrooms, a second full bath, and dedicated laundry room complete the convenient one-level layout. Outside, the mostly wooded 5-acre parcel offers privacy along with usable lawn surrounding the home, a fire pit area, and plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors. A separate cleared and level area on the property includes an existing pole barn providing covered storage with additional room for equipment and recreation. The home was placed here in 2023 along with a new septic system, followed by a drilled well in 2024, making this an opportunity where much of the work of establishing the property has already been done. Whether you’re looking for a year-round home or a Vermont getaway, this one puts acreage, water access, beautiful views, and four-season recreation all within reach.

6655 Us Route 5, Sutton

$369,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5109506 MLS

PRICE CHANGE!!! MOTIVATED SELLER!!!! Come check out this beautiful, move in ready, year round lake access property. It is a 3 bedroom 1 bath, with views and a dock on Blaisdell Lake. The home has a lovely entryway that leads into a cathedral style living room with skylights. The firepit will be an amazing place to enjoy memories with friends and family. Do not miss out!!! The house is close to trails, skiing and the lake provides activities year round. -New dock, Two kayaks, and new septic 2024. There is an opportunity to join the beach association for $100.00 a year.

199 Rte 114, Sutton

$479,000

5109377 MLS

*PRICE REDUCTION* INVESTORS: THIS IS A TWO FAMILY HOME! Situated on 3.4 acres at the end of a secluded dirt road in the bucolic town of Sutton, NH and nestled in the pines on a bluff overlooking Cascade Brook, lies this splendid two-family log cabin. With commanding sunset views over the water from the expansive deck and covered porch, the home is perfect for entertaining family and friends. The property boasts two separate living spaces. The three bedroom, two-story gambrel on one side, features a spacious kitchen/dining area with a wood stove and a French door that opens to an expansive deck, perfect for grilling and morning coffee. There is also a bedroom/office on the main floor and a 3/4 bath. Upstairs is the spacious primary bedroom with ample closet space and western views. Completing the second floor is another bedroom and a private office area as well. The walk-out lower level features a large family/entertainment room with a lovely wood stove for chilly evenings and an adjacent utility room with a washer and dryer. The "cabin style" side of the property features a spacious bedroom with generous closets and an en-suite full bath, a pine-paneled kitchen with terrific storage, a dining area, a living room and a traditional covered porch overlooking Cascade Brook. The possibilities are endless. Use both properties for your family as a "mother-in-law" apartment, rent one side for extra income, or use both properties for yourself! Enjoy nearby conservation land for hunting and fishing. 10 minutes to New London for shopping and dining. Close to everything, but a world away. Come take a look. Some furnishings negotiable. Sale subject to sellers finding suitable housing. OPEN HOUSE OCT 10TH 12-2

115 French Rd E, Sutton

$479,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5109352 MLS

*PRICE REDUCTION* INVESTORS: THIS IS A TWO FAMILY HOME! Situated on 3.4 acres at the end of a secluded dirt road in the bucolic town of Sutton, NH and nestled in the pines on a bluff overlooking Cascade Brook, lies this splendid two-family log cabin. With commanding sunset views over the water from the expansive deck and covered porch, the home is perfect for entertaining family and friends. The property boasts two separate living spaces. The three bedroom, two-story gambrel on one side, features a spacious kitchen/dining area with a wood stove and a French door that opens to an expansive deck, perfect for grilling and morning coffee. There is also a bedroom/office on the main floor and a 3/4 bath. Upstairs is the spacious primary bedroom with ample closet space and western views. Completing the second floor is another bedroom and a private office area as well. The walk-out lower level features a large family/entertainment room with a lovely wood stove for chilly evenings and an adjacent utility room with a washer and dryer. The "cabin style" side of the property features a spacious bedroom with generous closets and an en-suite full bath, a pine-paneled kitchen with terrific storage, a dining area, a living room and a traditional covered porch overlooking Cascade Brook. The possibilities are endless. Use both properties for your family as a "mother-in-law" apartment, rent one side for extra income, or use both properties for yourself! Enjoy nearby conservation land for hunting and fishing. 10 minutes to New London for shopping and dining. Close to everything, but a world away. Come take a look. Some furnishings are negotiable. Sale subject to sellers finding suitable housing. OPEN HOUSE OCT 10TH 12-2

115 French Rd E, Sutton

$429,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5108616 MLS

Tastefully renovated Ranch-style home on 4+ peaceful country acres with additional outbuildings in a beautiful location with fee-per-use boat launch to Blaisdell Lake close by! This timeless, comfortable, recently updated single-floor living home, with 2 bedrooms and 1 spa-like bath, has much to offer as a primary or secondary residence. For vehicles, toys, and hobbies, it boasts a large attached 26x28 2-car garage with storage above and hayloft door as well as a detached 20x30 garage on a concrete slab with power and lights. There is also a smaller wood-framed 18x20 barn with small stalls on the other side of the property that was used for animals at one point in time. The yard is mainly level with great exposure for gardens. The Seller has meticulously upgraded just about everything in the house, from the 200amp electric panel to the water heater to a new roof to all new windows to interior paint to, literally, the kitchen sink! Another notable perk is a large, light and bright Southern-exposed 3-season room, also completely redone with a metal roof to cap it off. The basement is concrete and dry and could easily be converted for additional living space like a 3rd bedroom or rec room. Seller works primarily from home and the property has High Speed Fiber Optic Internet, so you'll be well connected to the outside world as you enjoy your life here in the country, a short walk on a quiet dirt road to Blaisdell Lake. This is a textbook example of a "Turnkey Home" and, with its universal appeal, it won't last long. It's better in-person than in pics, so come take a tour and make it your own! Quick Close possible! Showings start at the Open Houses on Sat 9/12 & Sun 9/13 from 11-1pm.

87 Foothills Rd, Sutton

$480,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5108297 MLS

The quiet hills of Sutton Vermont hide a gem near phenomenal lakes & fishing, skiing, mountain biking, and Snowmobiling… A wonderful home or even a B & B opportunity exists in this large, comfortable Post & Beam house with spacious radiant addition & loft! The placid pond greets you on your drive up to this 4 bedroom home on 6 acres. The scent from the apple orchard with 40+ trees with the glimpse of mountains on the horizon as you step around the corner, is blissful on a sunny day. A major renovation by the long time owners has just been completed. Beautiful! It began in 2021 with a complete basement replacement & basement addition totaling 1,584 sq. ft. of heated space, all with new perimeter drains. The 24 X 24 ft addition with cathedral ceiling stands 2 stories tall with a loft & exterior upper balcony. The entire house was completed with all New plumbing, Roofing & Siding, Electrical revamp, new flooring throughout, windows, baseboard Heating system, a cozy pellet fireplace, and Radiant heat for the addition. Even a cement pad for B-ball or use it for a 2 car garage. Turn-Key and ready for the Good Life!

1148 Wheelock Rd, Sutton

$415,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5108213 MLS

Nestled along a quiet country road, this move-in-ready home is waiting for someone new to make it their own. Lovingly cared for by the sellers, it is now ready to begin its next chapter and welcome its new owners. Whether you are looking for a comfortable place to start your homeownership journey or ready to simplify and downsize, this home offers a wonderful opportunity to settle in and enjoy. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances, while the partially finished walk-out basement provides even more room to spread out, with a recreation/family room, third bedroom, and ¾ bathroom. Step outside and you’ll find plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. The spacious yard offers endless possibilities for gardens, gatherings, games, or simply relaxing and enjoying the peace and quiet of the country setting. There is room here to entertain friends and family and create the outdoor spaces you’ve always envisioned. And for those who love being on the water, the Blaisdell Lake Association is just minutes away. Membership is available for those who want to take advantage of the boating and recreational opportunities the lake has to offer. Come see if this charming country home is the place where your next chapter begins! QUICK CLOSE POSSIBLE!!

100 Foothills Rd, Sutton

$389,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5107568 MLS

This fully and lovingly renovated farmhouse is ready for its next chapter. This property has had extensive updates and improvements, while still maintaining the charm and features of a classic Vermont home. The large inviting kitchen features natural wood and stone accents, new appliances, along with a walk-in pantry with laundry hook up. Wood accents continue throughout the home, leading to a spacious living room, made cozy and warm by a pellet stove and hardwood floors. The first level includes an updated full bath, with a new tile shower and custom built in shelving. The second floor features a large primary bedroom, expanded to allow for incredible natural light, vaulted ceilings with decorative exposed beams, and generous closet space. Second floor also includes 2 additional bedrooms, and a remodeled 3/4 bath with tile shower. This home sits on a 2 acre lot, with open lawn space, fruit trees, running brook, and outdoor entertaining space on the porch and fire pit area. The 24'x40' garage is ready for your vehicles and equipment, fully insulated and heated, with 13’ raised ceiling and 10’ garage door, workbench, cabinets and upstairs storage space. Off the back side of the garage is a new 12'x36' overhang for even more covered storage for tools and equipment. The possibilities are endless and exciting with this turn-key home. This property also includes a 2.31 acre lot on Route 5A, this additional land is partial wetland, not suitable for a homesite but possible lot for a camper/tiny house/camp, or storage. Land is MLS listing #5075573

135 E Ridge Rd, Sutton

$310,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5105464 MLS

Welcome to the peace and quiet of Vermont's Northeast Kingdom with this exceptionally well-maintained, turnkey three-bedroom, two-bathroom home in Sutton. Built in 2007, this home perfectly blends rural serenity with modern convenience, offering an opportunity to embrace a homestead lifestyle. The interior is very well cared for and completely move-in ready, featuring a spacious layout designed for comfortable country living. Downstairs, the property features a fantastic basement, room for a pool table or bar and alongside tons of dedicated storage and a generous workspace perfect for hobbies, crafting, or home projects. Outside, four beautiful, open and wooded acres provide ample room for expansive organic gardens, small livestock, or simple outdoor recreation, all anchored by a sturdy, versatile barn that is ready for animals, a workshop, or equipment storage. While the setting feels very private surrounded by the soothing sounds of nature, it is situated on a main road, ensuring effortless year-round commuting, reliable winter plowing, and easy access to local utilities. This ideal location places you just minutes from the town of Barton and the beaches of Crystal Lake, a local favorite for summer swimming, boating, and fishing. Being centrally located in the Northeast Kingdom means you are never far from world-class recreation, from the legendary mountain biking at Kingdom Trails and skiing at Burke Mountain to vast networks of snowmobile and hiking trails right outside your door. Offered at an exceptional value of $325,000, this property is the ultimate basecamp for Vermont adventures and self-sufficient country living.

5051 Us Route 5, Sutton

$129,000

5 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5104752 MLS

Built in 1841 this classic Vermont farmhouse is situated on a 0.52 acre corner lot in the heart of Sutton. Full of original character and ready for its next chapter, this property offers spacious rooms, exposed wood beams, wide plank floors and brick chimneys. Surrounded by farms and historic village homes, yet still within reach of some of the North East Kingdom's greatest attractions and recreational opportunities. Bring your ideas and picture the possibilities! Property will likely not qualify for low down payment financing options.

15 Burke Rd, Sutton

Start Your Search

board logo Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated .